Burris: Apology bill has the force of law


Jerry Burris' column in today's Advertiser looks at the implications of the Hawaii Supreme Court's injunction against the sale of "ceded" lands in terms of what it means about the legal significance of the Apology bill.

This is something that we had extensive arguments about here on this blog (when I had comments), with those overthrow deniers arguing that the apology was "just a resolution" and doesn't have the force of law.

Here's what Burris has to say:
In 1993, when Congress (or rather, about five members of an otherwise fairly uninterested U.S. Senate) debated the so-called "Apology bill" for Native Hawaiians, Sen. Daniel Inouye argued it was merely a "simple apology" designed to set the nation's historical facts in order.

What Inouye was focused on were arguments that the Apology bill was the first step toward independence for Hawai'i. Nothing, he said, could be further from the truth.

That may be so. But it is now abundantly clear the Apology bill is far more than a mere token of remorse. It is, according to the state Supreme Court in its Jan. 31 opinion on a lawsuit involving ceded lands, the very law of the land.

Put it this way: The Apology resolution is the controlling law when it comes to ongoing questions about whether the overthrow of the monarchy was illegal, whether Hawaiians are due restitution for that overthrow and whether ceded lands (property that went from the Hawaiian government and crown to the U.S. and then to the state of Hawai'i) should be held in impregnable trust until that restitution debate is settled.

To each point, the legal answer, as declared by our highest court, is "yes."

I argued many times in the past that the apology was the official position of the U.S. regarding the overthrow, and now the court has confirmed that fact. And we should also remember that Prof. Boyle made this clear back then just after the law was passed:
...it's important when reading through this act, the so-called whereas clauses: these are official findings of fact and law, by the Congress of the United States. These findings bind all state and federal courts here in Hawai'i.

Indeed.

One reminder, though. While I agree that the apology is the "law of the land" for the U.S. regarding its policy and official position on the overthrow, the apology itself is misguided in one significant point: it defines Hawaii's government as a "Native Hawaiian government" and narrows the aggrieved party to only Native Hawaiians, attempting to channel the restitution of a country into "reconciliation" of a native domestic nation, and this is simply not the case. It was the government of the entire national population, including many natural-born and naturalized subjects who were not kanaka 'oiwi. All of them had their country illegally invaded and occupied and their government made ineffective through unlawful foreign intervention.

Burris says, "Opponents of this process argue it is unconstitutional to transfer assets from public control to one specific group on the basis of race."

But it should not be on the basis of race in the first place. It should be on the basis of nationality, and descendants of ALL Hawaiians nationals have a right to restore their country and reclaim their national lands. Taking this out of the native/racial framework and putting it into the proper national/political framework is the only way to correctly and meaningfully address the wrongs that were done, and move forward with a solid legal and historical foundation.


Posted: Wed - February 6, 2008 at 10:12 AM    
   
 
Categories
XML/RSS Feed
Search
World Court Case DVD
Larsen Case on DVD
Larsen DVD
Larsen v. Hawaiian Kingdom at the
Permanent Court of Arbitration
The Hague, 2001
DVD Mini-Documentary & Booklet
Order your copy
FREE HAWAII STICKERS
Free Hawaii
Over at the Free Hawaii blog, Koani Foundation is giving away "Free Hawaii" stickers and pins, and will post photos of them displayed in interesting places. Spread them far and wide!
HAWAII DOCUMENTS
HAWAII LINKS
HAWAII BLOGROLL
HAWAII FORUMS
HAWAII PODCASTING
PROGRESSIVE BLOGROLL
TV Worth Watching
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart
The Colbert Report
NOW with David Brancaccio
Foreign Exchange with Fareed Zakaria
Countdown with Keith Olbermann
Russell Simmons presents Def Poetry
Real Time with Bill Maher
Washington Journal on C-Span
PBN Friday with Howard Dicus
Portfolio
Archives
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
Browse archives by date
CURRENT IMAGE
Support Organ Donation
DONATE LIFE
Comments powered by
Weblog Commenting by HaloScan.com
TECHNORATI
Add to Technorati Favorites
SUPPORT THIS BLOG
If you find this weblog valuable, please consider making a secure donation via PayPal to support its ongoing maintenance:

Mahalo!
Or contact me about sponsoring this blog in exchange for space in the Sponsored Links area above.
Statistics
Total entries in this blog:
Total entries in this category:
Published On: Feb 06, 2008 10:24 AM
Powered by
iBlog


©