Twigg-Smith's revisionist history


Thurston Twigg-Smith continues his revisionist history in a letter in the Advertiser today, claiming that "Any student of Hawaiian history knows the revolution was instigated and carried out by a group of subjects of the kingdom, not the United States."

Twigg-Smith is actually correct in pointing out that there are factual errors with the 1993 Apology resolution, but these have to do not with the U.S. role, but with the apology being made exclusively to Native Hawaiians, when in fact the entire multi-racial citizenry of the Hawaiian Kingdom was affected by the United States' unlawful intervention in their country.

Twigg-Smith has the temerity to cite President Cleveland to support his claim, but let's look at what Cleveland actually said, in his Dec. 18, 1893 address to Congress, calling for the restoration of the legitimate government of Hawaii:
The lawful Government of Hawaii was overthrown without the drawing of a sword or the firing of a shot by a process every step of which, it may be safely asserted, is directly traceable to and dependent for its success upon the agency of the United States acting through its diplomatic and naval representatives.

But for the notorious predilections of the United States Minister for annexation, the Committee of Safety, which should be called the Committee of Annexation, would never have existed.

But for the landing of the United States forces upon false pretexts respecting the danger to life and property the committee would never have exposed themselves to the pains and penalties of treason by undertaking the subversion of the Queen's Government.

But for the presence of the United States forces in the immediate vicinity and in position to afford all needed protection and support the committee would not have proclaimed the provisional government from the steps of the Government building.

And finally, but for the lawless occupation of Honolulu under false pretexts by the United States forces, and but for Minister Stevens' recognition of the provisional government when the United States forces were its sole support and constituted its only military strength, the Queen and her Government would never have yielded to the provisional government, even for a time and for the sole purpose of submitting her case to the enlightened justice of the United States.
[...]
By an act of war, committed with the participation of a diplomatic representative of the United States and without authority of Congress, the Government of a feeble but friendly and confiding people has been overthrown. A substantial wrong has thus been done which a due regard for our national character as well as the rights of the injured people requires we should endeavor to repair.

Update 11/4: Io has a much more extensive response to Twiggy's letter at the "E Ala Mai | E Maliu Mai" blog, including the family history that engenders his revisionism.

Update 11/5: I was thinking about this more, and the thought occurred to me that Cleveland's version actually gives Twiggy's grandfather a slight bit of cover, because he could claim his actions were instigated by foreign intervention. And it was only because of this fact that Cleveland sought and gained the promise of amnesty from the queen. Otherwise Thurston's actions were treason, pure and simple, and would have been punishable as a capital offense under the penal code.

Update 11/6: Louis Vierra has a letter in response.

Update 11/11: Leslie Ching responds.

Update 11/14: My letter finally published (along with a good one on a related topic by Steve Laudig).

Update 11/16: Edwin Ramos has a letter although he mistakenly lumps Rolf Nordahl in with Twiggy, when Twiggy was actually responding to Rolf. Ramos also mentions the presence of the USS Boston, but fails to mention the actual landing of marines from the ship.


Posted: Thu - November 3, 2005 at 10:09 AM    
   
 
Categories
XML/RSS Feed
Search
World Court Case DVD
Larsen Case on DVD
Larsen DVD
Larsen v. Hawaiian Kingdom at the
Permanent Court of Arbitration
The Hague, 2001
DVD Mini-Documentary & Booklet
Order your copy
FREE HAWAII STICKERS
Free Hawaii
Over at the Free Hawaii blog, Koani Foundation is giving away "Free Hawaii" stickers and pins, and will post photos of them displayed in interesting places. Spread them far and wide!
HAWAII DOCUMENTS
HAWAII LINKS
HAWAII BLOGROLL
HAWAII FORUMS
HAWAII PODCASTING
PROGRESSIVE BLOGROLL
TV Worth Watching
The Daily Show with Jon Stewart
The Colbert Report
NOW with David Brancaccio
Foreign Exchange with Fareed Zakaria
Countdown with Keith Olbermann
Russell Simmons presents Def Poetry
Real Time with Bill Maher
Washington Journal on C-Span
PBN Friday with Howard Dicus
Portfolio
Archives
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
Browse archives by date
CURRENT IMAGE
Support Organ Donation
DONATE LIFE
Comments powered by
Weblog Commenting by HaloScan.com
TECHNORATI
SUPPORT THIS BLOG
If you find this weblog valuable, please consider making a secure donation via PayPal to support its ongoing maintenance:

Mahalo!
Or contact me about sponsoring this blog in exchange for space in the Sponsored Links area above.
Statistics
Total entries in this blog:
Total entries in this category:
Published On: Dec 27, 2005 10:13 PM
Powered by
iBlog


©