George Will on Akaka bill: Hawaiians = Nazis?
George Will's column
in the Washington
Post begins
thusly:"I decide who is a Jew around here."
-- Hermann Goering in 1934, when told that a favorite Munich art dealer was Jewish.
Under legislation that the House of Representatives has voted 261 to 153 to foist on Hawaii, Goering's role would be played by a panel empowered to decide who is a "Native Hawaiian" and entitled to special privileges and immunities. Because there are perhaps only 7,000 "pure" Native Hawaiians, "Hawaiian blood" will inevitably be the criterion, and the "one-drop rule" probably will prevail. Goering would have approved of this racialist sorting-out.
Ian
Lind says
on his
blog:What in the world was conservative columnist George Will smoking when he wrote yesterday’s column equating Native Hawaiian rights with Nazi racism? Do you think he really believes that stuff? What an ass.
Update
11/30: In the
Advertiser,
Akaka and others react
to Will's column. There's this note at
the end of the
article:Also opposed to the Akaka bill and federal recognition are those who believe much more is needed to address wrongs against Hawaiians. Some of those opponents believe Hawai'i should be restored as a nation wholly independent of the U.S.
Update
12/2:
Advertiser
editorializes.
Star-Bulletin
editorial
plus an op-ed
from Akaka and
Abercrombie.Update 12/3:
And now the
Maui News
has an editorial
condemning Will as well: "A more blatant misrepresentation or willful ignorance
of history would be hard to find."
Posted: Thu - November 29, 2007 at 07:09 AM