Apoliona commentary on federal recognition; poll problems go both
ways
OHA board chair Haunani Apoliona has a commentary
in the Advertiser
supporting federal recognition, taking on
conservative opponents of the bill, including their use of bogus
polls.We appreciate Rep. Abercrombie for citing for both colleagues and C-SPAN viewers, the specific, misleading question, successfully discrediting this "push" poll by Grassroot Institute of Hawai'i.
He immediately cited credible polls, which consistently find the majority of Hawai'i residents support federal recognition.
I
believe I was the first to call
out GIH over two years ago specifically for doing "push" polls, and
Abercrombie and Apoliona are right to point this
out.However, I would also remind
readers that OHA's own recent poll cited by Abercrombie and Apoliona was not
without problems of its own. As I noted
at the time and the
Star-Bulletin
editorial
pointed
out:...one question posed in the new survey was troublesome: "There has been talk about creating a Hawaiian governing entity that would represent the Hawaiian people in their dealings with the state and the federal government. Do you agree or disagree that an entity of some kind should be formed?"
Actually, there has been more than talk about such a governing body. The Akaka Bill explicitly calls for a "native Hawaiian governing entity to negotiate with federal, state and local governments, and other entities." Only 51 percent of the poll's respondents support it, while 34 percent disagree.
We have criticized a 2005 poll taken by the Grassroot Institute of Hawaii, which opposes sovereignty, because of a loaded question designed to elicit negative reactions to the Akaka Bill. The newest OHA poll deserves similar scrutiny for a misleading question implying that a Hawaiian governing entity is being talked about but is not part of the Akaka Bill. [Emphasis added.]
Posted: Mon - October 29, 2007 at 07:12 AM